Why Basic Home & Auto Insurance May Not Be Enough in Today’s Economy

In today’s volatile economy, relying solely on standard home and auto insurance may not offer the level of protection you need. Inflation is pushing up the costs of property repairs, medical bills, and legal settlements. At the same time, our lifestyles are becoming more interconnected and legally complex. If your current policies don’t keep up, you could face significant out-of-pocket expenses due to umbrella insurance coverage gaps.

That’s where umbrella insurance comes in.

Umbrella insurance provides an added layer of liability protection that kicks in when your home or auto policy limits are exhausted. It can be the safety net that protects your finances, your savings, and your future.

Helpful Facts

  • Inflation is widening insurance coverage gaps.
  • Basic policies may exclude personal injury and lawsuits.
  • Real-life claims often exceed standard policy limits.
  • Umbrella insurance adds $1M+ in extra protection.
  • It’s affordable and essential for most families.

In this article, we’ll explore:

  • Why inflation is increasing the risk of underinsurance
  • Common gaps in standard home and auto policies
  • Real-world scenarios where basic coverage falls short
  • How umbrella insurance works
  • Whether umbrella coverage is right for you

The Inflation Factor: Higher Costs, Bigger Risks

Inflation isn’t just hitting the grocery store. It’s also driving up the cost of building materials, vehicle parts, labor, and even legal fees. As a result, the coverage limits on your homeowners and auto insurance—which may have seemed sufficient a few years ago—may no longer cover the full cost of a claim.

For example:

  • Replacing a roof or remodeling after a fire can easily exceed the dwelling coverage limits of an older homeowners policy.
  • A serious auto accident involving multiple vehicles and injuries can lead to lawsuits with settlements well beyond the liability coverage in a basic policy.

Liability claims and repair costs have seen double-digit increases in recent years.

Hidden Gaps in Home and Auto Insurance

Even when policy limits are adequate, there are still many situations where basic home and auto insurance won’t protect you. Here are some of the most common and overlooked umbrella insurance coverage gaps:

1. Personal Injury Liability

If someone sues you for defamation, slander, or invasion of privacy—for example, from something posted online—your standard homeowners insurance may not cover legal fees or damages.

2. Household Member Liability

If your teenage child causes property damage or injury, your liability as a parent may not be fully covered by your policy.

3. Auto Accidents with High Medical Costs

Many drivers carry only the minimum required liability coverage. But what happens if you’re found responsible for an accident that results in a lawsuit and long-term medical bills?

4. Injuries on Your Property

Slip-and-fall claims or injuries at a pool or trampoline can lead to costly lawsuits—especially if the injured party hires legal representation.

Real-World Scenarios That Expose Umbrella Insurance Coverage Gaps

Here are a few examples of everyday events that could lead to massive out-of-pocket expenses if your coverage isn’t sufficient:

  • Dog Bite Lawsuit: Your dog bites a neighbor. They require surgery and sue for damages. The medical and legal costs exceed your homeowners liability limit.
  • Teen Driving Incident: Your teenager crashes into a luxury car, injuring the driver. The claim far exceeds your auto liability coverage.
  • Online Accusations: You or a family member are sued for defamation after making accusations on social media. Your homeowners policy doesn’t cover personal injury lawsuits of this type.

In each of these cases, umbrella insurance would provide additional coverage, often starting at $1 million.

What Is Umbrella Insurance?

Umbrella insurance is a supplemental liability policy that extends beyond the limits of your existing home and auto coverage. It can also cover claims that aren’t included in standard policies, such as:

  • Libel and slander
  • False arrest or detention
  • Legal defense fees
  • Property damage or bodily injury caused by members of your household

Umbrella policies are typically sold in $1 million increments and are surprisingly affordable—often costing between $150 and $300 per year for the first million in coverage.

Do You Need Umbrella Insurance?

Umbrella insurance isn’t just for the wealthy. It’s a smart move for anyone who:

  • Owns property
  • Drives regularly
  • Has children or pets
  • Hosts guests or parties
  • Has savings or retirement assets to protect
  • Is active on social media

If you’re at risk of being sued for more than your insurance will cover, an umbrella policy could save you from financial disaster.

How to Get the Right Coverage

  1. Review Your Existing Policies
    • Check the liability limits on your homeowners and auto insurance.
    • Make sure you meet the minimum coverage required to qualify for an umbrella policy.
  2. Talk to a Professional
    • An agent can help you identify your unique risks.
    • They can recommend coverage levels and shop across carriers for the best value.
  3. Consider Bundling
    • Many insurers offer discounts when you bundle home, auto, and umbrella insurance.

Protect More Than Just Your Home and Car

Basic insurance is a starting point. But in a world of rising costs and growing legal exposure, it may not be enough.

Umbrella insurance gives you peace of mind and financial security that extends far beyond your standard coverage. Avoid umbrella insurance coverage gaps with just a few dollars a month. And shield your hard-earned assets from life’s unexpected (and expensive) surprises.

Discover Essential Insurance Insights with Us!

At Coughlin Insurance Services, we understand the unique challenges of protecting your home and family and offer tailored insurance solutions to meet your needs. Our comprehensive coverage safeguards against risks ensuring your investments remain secure. By partnering with us, you gain access to expert guidance and robust protection, allowing you to have peace of mind.


You may have been recommended to us by one of our many satisfied customers, or you may have searched online for “insurance near me.” However you found us, we’re happy to welcome you. To discuss your needs and how we can help, please contact Pierre Bartalotta, Director of Personal Insurance, at email: Pierre@coughlinis.com or tel: (914) 833-4999. Reach out today for a free insurance quote!